The Bombs, the Church, the City, the State

Esquire

The Bombs, the Church, the City, the State

What was Alabama back then? And what is Alabama right now?

Getty

By Charles P. Pierce      December 11, 2017

BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA—There are certain iconic places from our history on which we can all pretty much agree—Bunker Hill, Fort McHenry, the Motown studios in Detroit and the Stax studios in Memphis. There are some iconic places from our history that are, at best, unsettling and, at worst, divisive as all hell. We saw that exercised over the past years in places like Liberty Place in New Orleans, where a monument to a successful act of white supremacist terrorism was finally moved into the obscurity it has long deserved.

And then there are certain iconic places from our history that make us avert our moral inner eyes because, while we admire the people that made these places historic, we remain uncomfortable with the situations that made that courage necessary. They put a flinch in our historical memory. Since the 1950s, Alabama has been awash in these places. There is Montgomery, where the bus boycott began. There is the bus station in Anniston, where a mob tried to burn the Freedom Riders to death. There are the stops along Route 80, where the great march from Selma to Montgomery passed in 1965. There is the Edmund Pettus Bridge.

Getty

And there is the 16th Street Baptist Church here in Birmingham, which has been a gathering place for African-Americans since it was finished in 1911. Paul Robeson sang there. W.E.B. DuBois and Mary McLeod Bethune spoke there. And, at 10:22 a.m. on September 15, 1963, a Sunday morning, a group of four white supremacist terrorists planted 15 sticks of dynamite in the church and blew it up, killing four little girls and injuring at least 20 other parishioners, and converted the 16th Street Baptist Church into one of those places that all Americans of a certain age know about instinctively, and one of those places that many Americans talk about with a familiar flinch in their memory.

The flinch keeps too many of us from remembering that this was the third bombing in Birmingham over the previous 11 days, and that the campaign of destruction came in the wake of a federal court decision mandating the integration of Birmingham’s public schools. The flinch keeps us from remembering that the people of the church rebuilt it in less than a year, that a stained-glass window was donated by some people in Wales who were shocked and disgusted by something that had happened in America. The flinch never has left our national mind. It keeps us from remembering that the forces that brought down the walls of the church still maintain a certain destructive power. The flinch is caused by something real, something dark, something alive.

Getty

In the years between 1995 and 1997, the Department of Justice under Bill Clinton was examining a series of arsons that had struck largely African-American churches in the South. The head of the DOJ’s Civil Rights division was a Massachusetts lawyer named Deval Patrick. It was the largest DOJ investigation ever conducted, prior to the probe into the attacks of September 11, 2001. (The investigation resulted in more than 100 arrests, but no evidence of a conspiracy linking the attacks ever was found—which, in some ways, makes the whole thing worse.) During the course of that investigation, Patrick and his team picked up some information regarding suspects in the church bombing who never had been brought to justice.

In 1977, a Ku Klux Klan member named Robert Chambliss had been tried and convicted for his part in the crime, but the FBI and other investigators long had been convinced that Chambliss hardly acted alone. Now, over 30 years later, the FBI went back through the vast files it had accumulated at the time of the bombing. Eventually, two aging Klansmen, Bobby Cherry and Thomas Blanton were arrested and tried for their part in the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing. The two were convicted. Cherry died in prison and Blanton is still there. The prosecutor who put them there was an assistant U.S. Attorney named Doug Jones. He looked at the two old murderers and the flinch was not in him. He put them away.

THE FLINCH IS CAUSED BY SOMETHING REAL, SOMETHING DARK, SOMETHING ALIVE.

On Sunday, in the middle of a crowd on the sidewalk in front of Jones’s Birmingham headquarters, a fine Stetson hat on his head, Armond Bragg was making a lot of noise, leading chants and cheers, and generally having a high old time for himself, listening to Senator Cory Booker. Bragg ran his own pest control business for 30 years until he retired. He did not go in much for politics until Barack Obama ran for president in 2008. Now, though, he has worked day and night for Doug Jones because Armond Bragg remembers when they called his town “Bombingham.” He is a member of the 16th Baptist Church, and, as such, he is not afflicted at all by the flinch.

“I’m a member of the 16th Street Baptist Church and Doug convicted the bombers there back during a time when that wasn’t popular to do, especially for a white man. Then, he prosecuted the guy who bombed the abortion clinic. (Eric Rudolph, who later bombed Olympic Park during the 1996 Olympic Games in Atlanta.) I’ve just been impressed with his career.

“It wasn’t popular to do back in the day. It’s not popular now. Look, you got a guy who’s running who’s got an impeccable record, when you look at his history. And we got on the other side, a guy who’s done everything wrong to tell you the truth. It’s a no-brainer, when you look at the records. When you look at the two individuals, there’s no comparison.

“Doug Jones has run an impeccable campaign. I mean, you can’t just reach for African-American votes. You got to reach into other communities, too. That’s what I think needs to be done. You got to have a man who can go into—well, ‘Flour Country,’ I guess we call it—and also come to the city. Somebody’s got to do that. Doug Jones is that man.”

Getty

In so many ways, while Roy Moore is running a ghost campaign, Doug Jones is running a haunted one. He called the entire city out on its flinch, and some people resent the hell out of the fact that he did. He called the anti-choice movement out on its toleration of its wilder fringes, and some people resent the hell out of that, too. But not all the ghosts in our history are evil. The spirits of Addie Mae Collins, Denice McNair, Carole Robertson, and Cynthia Wesley called out over the decades for the peace and the justice they deserved. In 2001, their cries finally were heard.

On his stump speech, Doug Jones often quotes, from memory, a passage taken from The Cure at Troy, Irish poet Seamus Heaney’s magnificent re-imagining of Sophocles’s ancient play, Philocetes.

History says, don’t hope on the side of the grave.’

But then, once in a lifetime, the longed for tidal wave of justice can rise up.

And hope and history rhyme.

Sometimes, that rhyme is an epic poem, an Iliad from inside a Birmingham jail. And sometimes, often, that rhyme is a nursery rhyme, sung by children playing hard at double-dutch, but only after Sunday school is over.

Respond to this post on the Esquire Politics Facebook page.

Jimmy Kimmel Shames the GOP for Not Funding CHIPS, Children Health Insurance Program.

ABC News

Jimmy Kimmel makes emotional return to Jimmy Kimmel Live with his son Billy by his side: “I was out last week because this guy had heart surgery, but look, he’s fine everybody!” http://abcn.ws/2yi3wuZ

Jimmy Kimmel makes emotional return to Jimmy Kimmel Live

Jimmy Kimmel makes emotional return to Jimmy Kimmel Live with his son Billy by his side: "I was out last week because this guy had heart surgery, but look, he's fine everybody!" http://abcn.ws/2yi3wuZ

Posted by ABC News on Tuesday, December 12, 2017

Watch this Republican senator try to explain why health care for 9 million children is losing funding.

Posted by Working Families Party on Tuesday, December 12, 2017

Welcome to the world’s first recycle mall.

EcoWatch

Welcome to the world’s first recycle mall. A mall that only sells recycled and repurposed items.

Read more on positive news for recycling: http://bit.ly/2BDzRSM

See More

Welcome to the world's first Recycle Mall!A mall that only sells recycled and repurposed itemsRead more on positive news for recycling: http://bit.ly/2BDzRSMvia Rob Greenfield

Posted by EcoWatch on Tuesday, December 12, 2017

Kenya’s Sarafu-Credit: Alternative Economies and Community Currencies Part 2.

Resilience

Kenya‘s Sarafu-Credit: Alternative Economies and Community Currencies Part 2.

By Niko Georgiades, originally published by P2P Foundation      December 7, 2017

Second of a three part series, Niko Georgiades takes on a journey through Greece’s post-capitalist alt. economy, this time by way of Kenya. Originally published in Unicorn Riot Ninja.

Athens, Greece – Experimenting with alternatives to capitalism has continued to become more popular as huge wealth divides devour chances of relieving poverty across the world. During the summer of 2017, a speaking engagement at the self-organized squat of Embros Theater in Athens, Greece, showcased alternatives to capitalism. In the second of our three part series on alternative economies and community currencies, we spotlight Kenya’s Sarafu-Credit.

Community currencies are types of complimentary currencies shared within a community that are utilized as a means of countering inequality, class, debt, accumulation, and exclusion.

With community currencies, lower-income communities are given the ability to improve living standards by building infrastructure sustainability through networks of sharing, providing access to interest-free loans, and increasing the economic viability of the community.

This is a major departure from conventional national currencies. Most are generated today through fractional reserve banking, wherein units (“broad money” or M3) are created at the bank when loans are instantiated and destroyed upon repayment.

Caroline Dama, Board member of Grassroots Economics

During economic slowdowns including the US Great Depression, the “velocity of money” drops as fractional currency is unavailable. Locally issued “Depression Scrip” substituted for fractional money in the 1930s. Today alternative currencies that improve velocity of money by distributing credit creation power to the whole population are taking root in many countries.

The first speaker of the discussion at Embros Theater was Caroline Dama, a Board member of Grassroots Economics (GE). GE is a “non-profit foundation that seeks to empower marginalized communities to take charge of their own livelihoods and economic future” in Kenya.

Will Ruddick, who started the Eco-Pesa (no longer in circulation), a complementary and community currency, founded Grassroots Economics in 2010, which has created six networks of community currencies that now works with over twenty schools and twelve hundred businesses in Kenya.

In 2013, 200 businesses, 75% of which were owned by women, became part of the new self-organized and self-determined community currency, Bangla-Pesa, in Mombasa’s largest slum, Bangladesh.

Kenya’s government quickly saw the formation of these community currencies as a threat. Five individuals involved with Bangla-Pesa, including Will Ruddick and Caroline Dama, were implicated on charges of undermining the national currency, the shilling. They were all eventually cleared of all charges and the Sarafu-Credit system continues to break new boundaries and change the narrative of alternative economic systems.

Sarafu Credit – Bengla-Pesa

Drastic economic and social inequalities run rampant throughout Kenya as at least 46 percent of its population is living in poverty. With basic needs like clean water and healthcare becoming hard to attain, the Sarafu-Credit community currency system was created as a safety net for citizens to improve living conditions.

The word sarafu means currency in the Kiswahilli language. Sarafu-Credit is a system of community currencies used as a “regional means of exchange supplementing the national currency system.

The community in Bangladesh, the biggest slum in Kenya’s second largest city, Mombasa, is very poor and has little access to the shilling, the national currency. Caroline Dama, from GE, stated that the community is “able to come together and come up with a system to exchange our goods and services” using “community dollars.

These community currencies are complimentary with the national currency and Caroline stated that not all of them work towards abolishing the current currency or system, but that they are “trying to make sure that the community banks have a way to survive in times that they wouldn’t otherwise survive.

“it’s a form of community governance and self-taxation … the community has been able to come up with its own rules to solve its own problems.” – Caroline

How the Sarafu-Credit system works

GE explains Sarafu-Credit as: “A network of businesses, schools, self-employed and informal sector workers form a cooperative whose profits and inventory are issued as vouchers for social and environmental services as well as an interest-free credit to community members. These vouchers circulate in the community and can be used at any shop, school, clinic or cooperative businesses and form a stable medium of exchange when the Kenyan Shilling is lacking. This injection of money into the community in the form of a community currency, based on local assets, increases local sales and helps directly develop the local economy. Sarafu-Credit, Grassroots Economics’ Kenyan Community Currency program, creates stable markets based on local development and trust.”

Caroline stated that only with a bottom-up approach can the community create economic equality. “Communities thrive when they are able to make their own decisions.”

Community currency gives that power to the people because they are talking to each other, they are able to exchange, and now they are meeting their basic needs, they have enough to sell and when they sell they can pool their resources together to build that better school.” – Caroline

Graph of how the Community Currency Vouchers operates

If we have problems in the society we want to deal with … what we do, is we can come together as businesses instead of waiting for the government to do it for us”, said Caroline, who stressed the importance of self-determination and community empowerment.

The community currency vouchers are issued for social services and mutual credit for all sustainable needs of the community.  According to the Grassroots Economics website, “The community currency circulates around the community helping to connect local supply and demand for people who lack regular access to national currency.

Furthermore, Caroline gave an example of women in a village collectively working on projects together, like helping each other build new houses. They would make each person in their network a new house and they would gather the material needed to build the house from other cooperative businesses.

There was a lively discussion with plenty of questions after the presentation on Sarafu-Credit’s Bangla-Pesa. One of the many questions focused on hatching new ideas around sharing-based communities, instead of exchange based communities that could present inequalities based on the ability of services to exchange. Caroline said,

We are trying to move into a community whereby we are recognizing individual talents … that there is diversity in the community and that we should move away from the idea that we should monetize that. We try to live in a community that recognizes peoples needs, not monetizing them.” – Caroline

Grassroots Economics have created a .pdf with their user guide and have plenty of resources on their website. The video below shows how the Bangla-Pesa works.

To hear the full speech and question session of Sarafu-Credit click here.
For further reading on the Bangla-Pesa, here are a few attention-worthy papers:

80 Prominent Alabama Pastors Just Penned A Brutal Letter Urging Voters To Reject Pedophile Roy Moore

Verified Politics

80 Prominent Alabama Pastors Just Penned A Brutal Letter Urging Voters To Reject Pedophile Roy Moore

By Benjamin Locke      December 11, 2017  

On the eve of the hotly contested special U.S. Senate election in Alabama tomorrow, a group of 80 protestant ministers from all over the state has taken the highly unusual step of publishing an open letter telling voters not to support Republican candidate Roy Moore because he is “not fit for office.”

“It is our belief that in light of Roy Moore’s extremist beliefs,” states the letter, “his patterns of behavior and the recent allegations against him, no person of faith can, in good conscience, support him or his religious nationalism.”

While the ministers state they are speaking personally, and not for their church or congregation, it is notable many of them come from Moore’s own Baptist background.

The pastors are clearly offended that Moore uses his religion to sell himself to voters when his history and views are contrary to what they believe Christianity represents.

“He and politicians like him have cynically used Christianity for their own goals,” says the letter. “But Roy Moore does not speak for Christianity, and he acts in ways that are contrary to our faith.”

The clergymen note that their concerns about Moore go beyond the charges by a number of women of sexual harassment of teenage girls.

“Christianity affirms God’s love for the neighbor and care for the most vulnerable in society: the widow, the foreigner, and the orphan,” says the letter. “But he has denigrated people from other countries and other faiths.” 

“He opposes the expansion of Medicaid which would provide basic healthcare for 400,000 poor and working Alabamians. He seeks to deny the most basic civil rights of our fellow citizens.”

“He has used racial slurs and casually referred to state-sponsored violence against lesbian and gay families.”

“Kindness and justice toward widows, orphans, and foreigners are priorities in the Bible but they are not priorities for him.”

The letter does not go into detail about Moore’s years ago seeking to date girls as young as 14, and aggressively going after other young women who had not yet reached majority age, but the message is clear about the clergymen’s disgust with his actions.

“Christianity abhors sexual coercion and violence,” says the letter.

“We repudiate the actions of religious and political leaders like Roy Moore who have sought to silence, to cover up, and to be complicit in the sexual abuse,” adds the letter. “These actions reopen wound of anyone who has been abused by leaders who should have been committed to compassion, to justice and to healing God’s world.”

“It is beyond indefensible to use religion to shield one’s self from allegations of pedophilia and sexual abuse,” concludes the pastors. 

In calling Moore unfit for office, the pastors make clear it is not just about his unacceptable sexual history, but also about his more recent extremist positions, including his anti-LGBTQ and anti-Muslim bigotry, anti-choice extremism, and his contempt for the rule of law.

The letter says each person must vote as they see fit but adds that in their opinion “no person of faith can, in good conscience, support him or his religious nationalism.”

“He has done harm to our government;” continues the letter, “he has done harm to ur Christian witnesses; and he has done harm to vulnerable people.”

This letter is important because it gives the lie to Moore’s contention that he represents the Christian point of view and has the support of all religious people in a state known for being more religious than most others.

Moore’s wife also released a letter from about 50 ministers who support her husband, but she did not mention that it was an old letter, and many of those who signed now repudiate Moore and want no part of him or his campaign.

covered with the blood@NannetteGordon3: Roy Moore & his wife literally took an old letter of support by 53 pastors, and forged it to make it seem like he was still supported AFTER the allegations of sexual assault on minors came out.

So far, multiple people named in the letter have demanded they be removed from it. pic.twitter.com/rj1AsrHjbO

The real letter denouncing Moore, just written,  sends the message that what Moore has done and what he stands for is not in keeping with the mainstream, even among churchgoers, and that he cannot claim the moral high ground when his views and actions make him a national embarrassment. 

Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) Begins To Realize The Terrible Mistake She Made 

Daily Kos

Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) Begins To Realize The Terrible Mistake She Made

By Dartagnan       December 08, 2017

WASHINGTON, DC - DECEMBER 5: Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) walks to the Senate floor as she leaves a meeting with Senate Republicans on Capitol Hill, December 5, 2017 in Washington, DC. After the Senate passed their tax reform legislation last week, the next step will be a conference committee with members of the House to iron out the differences between the two bills. (Drew Angerer/Getty Images)No wonder she doesn’t look happy. She screwed Mainers and herself.

You may recall Senator Susan Collins (R-ME) basking in the limelight last week during the run-up to the GOP’s vote to ram through its catastrophic tax giveaway to corporations and other Billionaires at the expense of the rest of the American public.

As one of the so-called “moderate” Republicans, her vote was solicited with tender care by Mitch McConnell, the Senate Majority Leader, who apparently promised her that the American middle class might, just might still retain some meager crumbs left over from his Party’s loot-fest of the public treasury in the form of keeping their property tax and medical expense deductions. She also obtained an “assurance” from McConnell that a 4% cut to Medicare would certainly never be included in the final Bill, once it was reconciled with the version devised by the good, caring Republicans in the House. Hey, she had it in writing!

“There’s a real fear that the tax bill is going to trigger a 4% cut in Medicare,” Collins added. “I am absolutely certain that 4% cut in Medicare that I mentioned will not occur. I have it in writing from both the Speaker of the House Paul Ryan and also Senator Mitch McConnell.”

But even these tiny, miserable morsels casually tossed to ordinary Americans were coldly eliminated and deemed too much of a sacrifice to the Super-yacht class and their proxies in the Republican Congress:

News reports this week revealed that House Speaker Paul Ryan told congressional staff after the Senate vote that he was not a party to McConnell’s promise to pass the provisions that Collins demanded.

“She made a political error that’s going to cost Mainers and cost people across the country basic lifelines while [helping] the wealthy,” said [Marie Follaytar] Smith,” [an activist and co-founder of Mainers for Accountable Leadership].

In fact it’s absolutely clear that Medicare is next on the chopping block for Ryan’s willing executioners, precisely as a result of the tax scheme Collins voted for:

As the tax cut legislation passed by the Senate early Saturday hurtles toward final approval, Republicans are preparing to use the swelling deficits made worse by the package as a rationale to pursue their long-held vision: undoing the entitlements of the New Deal and Great Society, leaving government leaner and the safety net skimpier for millions of Americans.

Now faced with a severe backlash back home, the former It-girl with well-known aspirations for the Maine Governorship is feverishly backtracking on her blunder:

Republican Sen. Susan Collins said she may change her vote on the Senate tax bill if amendments she added are not included in the final bill.

Collins believes the amendments she added in the Senate version on property tax and medical expense deduction for retirement funding improved the bill and that in time, it will lower the debt.

But as she told WMTW’s media partner, WABI, if those changes are not included in the final package, she will consider changing her vote.

That’s what tends to happen when you have nine religious leader activists getting themselves arrested occupying your office back home to protest what can most charitably be described as your utter naiveté if not outright stupidity:

It was the second group of protesters this week to be arrested in the offices of Maine’s senior senator while urging her to reject the sweeping changes to the federal tax code that are presently being negotiated in Washington, D.C. On Monday, police arrested five protesters, who had staged a sit-in at Collins’ Bangor office.

But the problem for Collins is that the GOP doesn’t need her anymore. With Mike Pence available to break any ties, and Bob Corker (R-TN) the only recorded Republican “no” vote in the Senate, they already have the votes to pass this monstrosity without her, in whatever mutated form the House disgorges back.

Instead, when Collins comes home and settles down in front of the TV with a nice cup of cocoa this holiday season, she’ll be treated to this ad sponsored by a group called Save My Care:

“Senator Collins said Republican leaders promised her they would fix things,” the narrator intones, while headlines about resistance in the House to her bills flash on the screen. “Now we know they lied to her and Mainers will suffer the consequences.”

But had she done the right thing by her constituents to begin with instead of trusting in a Party that actively recruits child molesters into its ranks, she wouldn’t be in the position she finds herself now, when it’s too late.

Alabama’s poverty, sewage crisis ‘very uncommon in First World’

UPI

U.N. official: Alabama’s poverty, sewage crisis ‘very uncommon in First World’

By Ray Downs        December 10, 2017

Open sewage in rural Alabama has been blamed for spreading diseases like hookworm and E. Coli. Photo by Philip Alston/UN/Twitter

December 10, 2017 (UPI) — A United Nations official investigating poverty in the United States visited Alabama last week and said the poverty and sewage system problems there are some of the worst he has seen in the developed world.

“I think it’s very uncommon in the First World. This is not a sight that one normally sees,” said Philip Alston, the UN’s Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human right, AL.com reported. “I’d have to say that I haven’t seen this.”

Alston is on a 15-day trip of the United States to investigate poverty and visited several counties in Alabama’s “Black Belt” region, a mostly black region that hag long experienced poverty and racial segregation.

One of the issues Alston focused on was the longstanding sewage crisis there.

“Lowndes County in rural Alabama, I saw homes that are not connected to public sewage systems, whose owners can’t afford to install septic tanks,” Alston tweeted Friday. “Many resort to digging ditches & straight piping waste water to within meters of homes, posing serious health risks.”

Local resident and activist Aaron Thigpen has lived in the Black Belt region his entire life, according to AL.com. He showed Alston where he lives — an area where diseases like E. Coli and hookworm, which are both eradicated in most of the country, thrive because there is scarce access to clean drinking water due to the sewage problem.

“These two pipes are the raw sewage pipes coming from the house. And you’ve got your main water line here, and it may have a hole in it, so everyone gets sick all at once,” Thigpen said. “It’s really bad when you’ve got a lot of kids around like there are here. They’re playing ball and the ball goes into the raw sewage, and they don’t know the importance of not handling sewage.”

According to the 2017 Alabama Poverty Data Sheet, nearly 20 percent of Alabamians live below the federal poverty line; nine counties have a poverty rate higher than 30 percent; and the child food insecurity rate is 24 percent (the national average is 18 percent).

Alston said he wants his visit to increase awareness of poverty in the United States, including rural Alabama.

“The hope is that we’ll bring attention to [these problems], just like we bring attention to people who are being tortured,” he said.

Related UPI Stories

Poll: Medicaid recipients report poorest health

Study: Top 1 percent owns 40 percent of nation’s wealth, highest point in 50 years

HUD: Homeless numbers up for first time since 2010

Donald Trump, Roy Moore, and the Degradation of the G.O.P.

The New Yorker

Donald Trump, Roy Moore, and the Degradation of the G.O.P.

In less than a year, the President, with help from the Alabama Senate candidate, has so damaged the Party that it may never recover.

By Amy Davidson Sorkin

Illustration by Tom Bachtell

When Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House spokeswoman, was explaining last week why President Trump had chosen to endorse Roy Moore in this week’s special election for the U.S. Senate, in Alabama, she made the decision sound natural—and perhaps, in the current political moment, it was. Moore may be facing multiple allegations that he preyed on teen-age girls (he has denied “sexual misconduct”), but Trump, Sanders said, sees him as “a person that supports his agenda.” That prompted a reporter to wonder how much of an agenda they shared. Does Donald Trump, he asked, “agree with Roy Moore that Muslims should not be allowed to serve in Congress?” “I haven’t asked him about a past statement from Roy Moore,” Sanders said. Her answer just about summarizes the nihilism of Trump’s Washington, where, when questioned whether the President would ban a religious group from Capitol Hill, his spokeswoman won’t say for sure without checking.

In less than a year in office, Trump has led the G.O.P. into situations and alliances so degraded that the Party may never fully recover, even as he watches an investigation into Russia’s possible interference in the 2016 election, led by Special Counsel Robert Mueller, move ever closer to his immediate circle. Last week, Donald Trump, Jr., refused to answer questions before the House Intelligence Committee about his conversations with his father, and a plea deal that Mueller struck with Michael Flynn, the former national-security adviser, indicates that Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, may be under scrutiny, too. Mueller may also have turned his attention to records related to Trump’s finances. Last Monday, the day that Trump endorsed Moore, Axios reported that one of the President’s lawyers, echoing Richard Nixon, had suggested that what might count as obstruction of justice for others would not in Trump’s case—because if the President does it, it isn’t really a crime. But each day dawns with a possibility that Trump will disgrace the Presidency more than he already has, whether he is insulting Native Americans or mangling relationships with our most trusted allies.

It would be inaccurate, though, to say that the President has acted alone, or without the cooperation of his party. There have been a few eloquent protests from members of Congress who are retiring or seem to think that they have nothing left to lose politically. After the Washington Post first published reports of Moore’s predation, several Republicans denounced him, and the Republican National Committee pulled out of a joint fund-raising agreement with him. But, last week, when Trump let the R.N.C. know that he was supporting Moore, it began pouring money into his campaign. “The President says jump and the RNC jumps,” a party official told the Wall Street Journal.

The Senate Majority Leader, Mitch McConnell, for his part, backed away from his own previous condemnation of Moore, saying on “Face the Nation,” “The people of Alabama are going to decide a week from Tuesday who they want to send to the Senate. It’s really up to them.” There had been talk that McConnell and his colleagues might help mount a write-in candidacy, or take some other measure to block Moore. Polls showing that Moore still had a good chance of beating the Democratic challenger, Doug Jones, apparently persuaded McConnell to rethink his position. (On Wednesday, however, he joined calls for Senator Al Franken, Democrat of Minnesota, to resign, which Franken said he would do.)

McConnell’s acquiescence is all the more striking since he has become a useful symbol of the Party establishment that Moore professes to oppose. Last Tuesday, at a rally in Fairhope, Alabama, which Steve Bannon, the President’s former chief strategist, also attended, Moore told the crowd that he knew that Trump was “trying so hard” to do everything he had promised during the campaign—end Obamacare, tear up nafta, build the wall. He was just being held back by the likes of McConnell.

Yet Moore, for all his talk of independence, was also selling himself as a party-line voter. What made the special election special, he said, was that “we’re going to see if the people of Alabama will support the President.” (He warned his audience that Jones is not only a Democrat but had been “a Barack Obama delegate.”) If his project in Washington would be loyalty to Trump, that would make him, by current standards, a fairly typical Republican. Indeed, one of Moore’s priorities, in addition to getting Americans to “go back to God,” is the tax bill that McConnell is struggling to pass. Trump had framed his own support for Moore in terms that McConnell would appreciate, tweeting, “We need his vote on stopping crime, illegal immigration, Border Wall, Military, Pro Life, V.A., Judges 2nd Amendment and more.” But what does it mean to “need” Roy Moore’s vote?

It’s possible, given the formalities of each process, that the winner of the Alabama race will be seated in the Senate before a vote on the final version of the tax bill is taken. If Doug Jones manages to win, the speed with which a final bill would be pushed through, to avoid having him vote on it, might stun even Washington. With or without Moore, however, the bill is an extraordinarily sloppy and reckless concoction: its benefits are concentrated at the top, and it casually sabotages the health-insurance system. The cost will be in untreated illnesses and unpayable medical bills. In the tally of amorality, for McConnell to accept being mocked by Moore on the campaign trail, and then have lunch with him on Capitol Hill before the roll call, may be nothing more than a rounding error.

At the rally in Fairhope, Moore reminisced that, when Trump was elected, it was as if “a big weight had been taken off my shoulders,” and asked if others had felt, as he did, “like we had another chance.” The Republicans have a fifty-two-seat majority, meaning that Moore’s presence would be helpful but, in terms of control of the chamber, not decisive. What would they tolerate in order to secure the fifty-first vote? Put another way, if the Party is willing to give its money and its credibility to protect a candidate accused of molesting teen-agers, what might it talk itself into doing to protect the President? Robert Mueller may be interested in the answer. ♦

This article appears in the print edition of the December 18 & 25, 2017, issue, with the headline “How Low Will They Go?” 

Amy Davidson Sorkin is a New Yorker staff writer. She is a regular Comment contributor for the magazine and writes a Web column, in which she covers war, sports, and everything in between.

U.S. not granting loan relief to defrauded students: inspector general

Reuters

U.S. not granting loan relief to defrauded students: inspector general

By Lisa Lambert, Reuters     December 11, 2017  

FILE – In this Oct. 13, 2017, file photo, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos speaks during a dinner hosted by the Washington Policy Center in Bellevue, Wash. DeVos says college students will soon be able to file their applications for federal student aid through a mobile app. DeVos is pledging to modernize the financial aid applications and make it more accessible and simpler. She spoke Tuesday at a conference of student aid professionals in Orlando, Florida. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Education Department under President Donald Trump and Secretary Betsy DeVos has stopped cancelling the student-loan debt of people defrauded by failed for-profit schools and those borrowers face mounting interest and other burdens, its inspector general said on Monday.

DeVos is seeking to redo the process for cancelling the debts of people who attended Corinthian Colleges, which collapsed in 2015 amid government investigations into its post-graduation rates, and other failed schools.

In the final days of his administration, President Barack Obama approved rules speeding up the debt cancellations. DeVos has delayed implementing those rules, saying they would create significant costs for taxpayers.

According to a report by the inspector general, DeVos also brought the existing cancellation process to a crawl.

Since Trump’s inauguration on Jan. 20, the department has received 25,991 claims for discharging loans. It has denied two requests and approved none, the inspector general, an independent auditor within the agency, found.

That is in contrast to Obama’s final months in office. From July 1, 2016, through inauguration, the department received 46,274 claims and approved 27,986. It denied none.

Caught in limbo, borrowers are seeing interest and fees accrue and their credit damaged, the inspector general’s report showed. Borrowers could ultimately owe more on a denied discharge than if they had not asked for cancellation and simply continued making payments, the inspector said.

Some state attorneys general have pushed the department to cancel the loans, saying students cannot afford to repay the often-large amounts because the schools did not give them adequate training or a diploma.

The inspector general also found the department did not have a sufficient information system and had to manually retrieve claims data.

“Hundreds of thousands of students were defrauded and cheated by predatory colleges that broke the law, but today’s report confirms Secretary DeVos tried to shirk her responsibility to these students and shut down the borrower-defense program, leaving them with nowhere to turn,” said Senator Patty Murray, the senior Democrat on the Education Committee.

In a memo to the inspector general, A. Wayne Johnson, chief operating officer of the federal student aid program, said the department has “authorized an interest credit” for long-outstanding claims, will resume reviewing some claims and will soon approve claims for 11,000 Corinthian students.

(Reporting by Lisa Lambert; Editing by Cynthia Osterman)